Source: Radio New Zealand (world)
An F/A-18E Super Hornet participates in an air power demonstration over the aircraft carrier USS John C. Stennis.
Photo: STOCKTREK IMAGES / AFP
The prime minister insists the government is not going to review New Zealand’s nuclear-free stance, and doing so would be detrimental to our relations with other countries, according to a former defence minister.
Though the opposition is sceptical of the government’s commitment to the four-decade-old stance.
Defence Minister Chris Penk, speaking at a security summit in Singapore last week, said it would be helpful to have a conversation about nuclear propulsion, to the extent that it is different to nuclear weapons.
There was no policy along those lines, Penk said, but it would be “helpful” for the country to have “a conversation”, given Australia was slated to acquire three nuclear-powered submarines as part of the AUKUS deal.
“Traditionally the New Zealand public has been very sceptical about nuclear weapons, which might be an interesting conversation in terms of the extent to which that’s different to nuclear propulsion.”
New Zealand does not allow nuclear-propelled vessels into its waters, whether they carry weapons of the sort or not.
The Labour Party said the government needed to clarify its position. Coming after Christopher Luxon’s comments last week to the house supporting nuclear energy, the government seemed to be signalling a change of policy, Labour leader Chris Hipkins said.
After becoming prime minister in 2023, Luxon said the nuclear ban was “non-negotiable”.
A spokesperson for Luxon said that had not changed.
ACT MP Cameron Luxton on Tuesday told RNZ’s First Up there were no plans to change New Zealand’s almost four-decade nuclear-free stance.
“Chris Penk’s made those comments and… the prime minister has quite clearly said that’s not on the table. And I think that’s a fair enough position,” he said.
“New Zealand has got a tradition of nuclear-free status. It’s not something we should be rubbing in the face of the world, but it is something that we should be respectful of that is a part of our tradition.”
The country has formally been a nuclear-free zone since the passing of the New Zealand Nuclear Free Zone, Disarmament, and Arms Control Act 1987. The closest it came to reversing course was when then-leader of the National Party, Don Brash, reportedly told US officials in 2004 the ban would be “gone by lunchtime” should his party be elected in 2005.
Former Defence Minister Wayne Mapp, who served under Prime Minister John Key, said any conversation was a “non-starter” and potentially even detrimental to our global relationships.
Wayne Mapp.
Photo: Pool / Fairfax Visuals
“Australia and New Zealand have already had a conversation on that,” he told Morning Report on Tuesday. “Australia does not expect to send its submarines into New Zealand ports. They know full well our policy.
“I recall from 2006 when John Key became our leader, one of the things we did as a party was to remove all doubt as to where National stood on this issue. And when we did that, our relationship – particularly with the United States – improved because they weren’t sort of niggling at us all the time to sort of review the policy.
“Once they knew where we stood we could then talk about the things we agreed on, not the things that we disagreed on.”
No nukes, no AUKUS – Labour
It was nothing new for the National Party, which had wanted to get rid of the nuclear-free policy for many years, Labour leader Chris Hipkins said.
“This is just the National Party doing what the National Party does. Don Brash said that if he’d been elected prime minister, nuclear free would be gone by lunchtime… this is just another example of that.”
Hipkins reaffirmed Labour’s position that New Zealand would not be part of AUKUS.
“It’s ultimately designed to bring nuclear power submarines into the Pacific – we don’t support that,” he said. “We don’t see that aligned with our strategic interests, and we don’t think New Zealand should be part of it.”
Christopher Penk.
Photo: NICK MONRO / RNZ
Penk said New Zealand was on track to meet its goal of doubling the defence budget to 2 percent of GDP. The war in Iran had highlighted the “perils of instability” and could lead the government to bring forward the timeline for reaching that goal, he said.
This came after US Secretary of War (formerly Secretary of Defense) Pete Hegseth accused New Zealand – among other nations – of “freeloading” off the US.
Cameron Luxton.
Photo: VNP / Phil Smith
ACT’s Luxton backed the hike in military spending.
“We cannot continue to live down here in the beautiful South Pacific and not be aware of what risks and issues are developing in the world,” he told First Up.
“New Zealand needs to play our part, and that’s what an uplift in spending is doing… We’ve got a massive wet blue continent to keep an eye on, an EEZ that extends a long way out and covers a lot of the Pacific Ocean surface that we’ve got to monitor. So this is something that is not before time.”
He said as a partner in the ‘Five Eyes’ intelligence network, New Zealand needed to be “acting like a partner”.
“We are not descended from fearful people. We have played a proud part in New Zealand and the history of the world defending liberal values, freedoms and decency. And we have to do the same in our world today because it’s not just us today, it’s our nation’s future that we need to look after.”
Mapp questioned whether such a large increase in spending was desired or even necessary. Hegseth wanted nations to spend 3.5 percent of GDP.
“To be honest, a lot of nations in the Asia-Pacific are not going to reach 3.5 percent because circumstances do not warrant it. This particular administration in the United States, that is, how long are they going to be around for with that level of expectation?
“The Asia-Pacific is in a different set of circumstances to Europe, for instance, where they have a major ongoing war, Ukraine, and it obviously leads to a different set of expectations. Our situation is very different to that.”
He did however note New Zealand had a larger than usual area to patrol with only two frigates.
“A lot of the time that means we have zero frigates.”
Penk last week said replacement options for the two aging vessels were being looked into.
Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
Copyright © 2026, Radio New Zealand
• ACT MP Cameron Luxton on nuclear policy and defence spending
5:52 am today
ACT MP Cameron Luxton joins First Up to discuss NZ’s nuclear position and the defence spending allocation in the budget. Audio
ACT MP Cameron Luxton on nuclear policy and defence spending
ACT MP Cameron Luxton joins First Up to discuss NZ’s nuclear position and the defence spending allocation in the budget. Audio
• AUKUS: Australian nuclear submarine programme to cost up to $394.5b
14 Mar 2023
Britain and the US will help Australia develop a nuclear-powered submarine programme, as part of the AUKUS pact.
AUKUS details unveiled: Australian nuclear submarine programme to cost up to $394.5 billion
AUKUS: Australian nuclear submarine programme to cost up to $394.5b
Britain and the US will help Australia develop a nuclear-powered submarine programme, as part of the AUKUS pact.
• Luxon ‘exploring’ non-nuclear part of AUKUS pact
21 Dec 2023
The PM has returned from Sydney, using stronger language about defence cooperation with Australia.
Luxon ‘exploring’ non-nuclear part of AUKUS pact
Luxon ‘exploring’ non-nuclear part of AUKUS pact
The PM has returned from Sydney, using stronger language about defence cooperation with Australia.
• Gone by lunchtime stoush erupts again
2 Sep 2014
A decade-old stoush between the former leader of the National Party, Don Brash, and Labour’s foreign affairs spokesperson Phil Goff has erupted again. Audio
Gone by lunchtime stoush erupts again
Gone by lunchtime stoush erupts again
A decade-old stoush between the former leader of the National Party, Don Brash, and Labour’s foreign affairs spokesperson Phil Goff has erupted again. Audio
• NZ aiming for steady rise in defence spending
30 May 2026
The increases are to meet a target of spending 2 percent of GDP on the military within eight years, Defence Minister Chris Penk says.
NZ aiming for steady rise in defence spending
NZ aiming for steady rise in defence spending
The increases are to meet a target of spending 2 percent of GDP on the military within eight years, Defence Minister Chris Penk says.
• Non-negotiable: Christopher Luxon says nuclear-free stance not changing
• NZ exploring all options for Moana Pasifika future, Winston Peters tells Pacific leaders
• Oil prices jump as Iran suspends peace talks
for ad-free news and current affairs
• Roads warnings, closures remain as MetService lifts warnings for top of South Island
• NZTA pauses using billboard cameras to detect WOF fraud, despite success
• Biggest KiwiSaver managers lagging in returns
• Dental expert Murray Thomson turns mythbuster over online advice